Once you’ve decided what type of editing you’re looking for and have determined your budget, it’s time to find an editor. This might be the moment where you’re shaking your head in panic. Things are tight, and you can’t afford to sink too much into a book that might not pay you back, even if it is your dream.
That’s okay! Your budget is not going to get in the way of your goal. By applying just a few tweaks, you can assess your manuscript’s needs just as described in Types of Editing and What Type of Editing Do I Need?. It also may be worth asking your editor(s) if they provide discounts for people in financial need. You’ll never know if you don’t try!
Initial Self-Editing
This step is the same regardless of your budget. Your job is simple—to read through the manuscript and fix any obvious mistakes. It’s going to be very difficult to read the story if you can’t read the writing, so make sure obvious typos are corrected, you’ve used punctuation like periods and quotation marks, you have paragraph breaks so your manuscript isn’t just a wall of text, and you’ve stayed (mostly) in the same tense from the same point of view. You’re not trying to make anything perfect, just good enough that you can focus on the story without the writing blocking your way.
Alpha Reader
The alpha reader is the first audience, so by definition, you will have one at some point. Your life will be easier if it’s sooner than later. Their job is to read the story and tell you if it made sense, if they cared about the characters, if the plot was interesting, and anything big-picture that jumped out at them. Anyone can alpha read, so long as they’re willing to be honest and engaged. Many people use Facebook groups, Reddit threads, or Discord communities to find feedback, and people will often swap manuscripts as a free way of getting it. This previous article talks about how to find alpha readers and what to do with their feedback when you get it.
Manuscript Evaluation
A manuscript evaluation, also called a story critique, manuscript assessment, or editorial assessment, is a broad-scale report on aspects of your story. You’ll get similar feedback as from a (good) alpha reader, but with specific ideas about how to implement the changes and ideas for future drafts. If you can afford one, a manuscript evaluation can serve the function of a developmental edit, but for much cheaper because it’s an outside document with no changes in-line. It’s up to you to put the feedback into action. While this traditionally goes between alpha and beta reading, if you’re on a really tight budget you might choose to do some editing of your own before getting one.
Beta Readers
All manuscripts need beta readers. You can find people who beta read for free in Facebook groups, on Instagram, at your family dinners, or at a local book club. Remember, beta readers aren’t necessarily professionals. They’re just people who like to read and are willing to answer a few questions afterward. This previous article talks about how to find beta readers and what to do with their feedback when you get it.
Developmental Edit
If your beta readers are largely confused, a developmental edit would be helpful. Given how expensive this can be, it’s likely to be a stage you’re tempted to skip. Don’t! With a few hours and a handful of notecards, you can figure out your manuscript’s structure. [Article incoming!] After making these big changes, it’s worth doing another round of beta reading to see how your readers respond. (And remember, if you still need help, a manuscript evaluation can be slotted in here for a lower price point than a full developmental.)
Line Edit
The next step in the editing process is line editing. When you’ve done big-picture work and feel happy with the story itself, it’s time to focus on the words. Consider whether your budget can stretch to cover a freelancer. You can often find beginner editors on freelancing websites for affordable prices, and it’s ideal to have different sets of eyes on your manuscript. You’re already so familiar with it you may not see the forest for the trees, especially after having read it so many times! If that’s not an option, there are some basic line edits you can make yourself. [Article incoming!]
Copy Editing
After (or sometimes concurrent with) line editing, is copy editing. A copy edit is more technical than line editing, and it serves to make sure everything is consistent and correct. If Zephaniah has black hair at in chapter one but is swooping blond bangs from his eyes in chapter two, your readers are going to have questions. And they’ll definitely notice if you change the spelling of your magical city’s capital halfway through, even if you don’t. Same as before, consider whether you can hire a freelancer for a fresh set of eyes. Your manuscript will be better for it, and your wallet doesn’t have to crumble in the process.
Proofread
Getting another set of eyes to proofread is important. You know how they say “Write the story you want to read”? Part of that is because you read your own work so many times. When you’ve already gotten used to your work you’re less likely to notice smaller technical errors, so it’s preferable to have someone who isn’t familiar with your manuscript proofread.
Because proofreading looks for things like punctuation and missing words rather than larger story problems, you can split up your manuscript for multiple proofreaders. Consider swapping chapters with another author to proofread, or giving away chapters to friends to proofread as a “sneak peek.”
If all else fails, put aside your manuscript for a few weeks and add a reminder to your calendar to pull it back out for proofreading. Even a little break can refresh your eyes and help you find new mistakes. You could also change the “environment” your words are in by switching up the fonts, sizes, or even your word processor. The text will look different to your brain and it will be easier to find mistakes. Remember, if you don’t know for sure if something is correct, look it up. The internet is a wealth of knowledge and it’s much better to spend a few minutes searching than to publish a book with errors.
Format
While it is possible to format your own book (especially if it’s not too complex and you’re already good with technology), this might be an area you want to hire out. Getting an ebook format is typically pretty affordable, and you can always come back and publish a paper/hardback later when you have the money. If you really want to do it yourself, familiarize yourself with your publishing platform’s rules and guidelines as well as getting comfortable with your word processor. You’ll find it useful to look at traditionally published books and their layouts, to avoid looking like what’s disdainfully referred to as “hybrid.” The internet is a wealth of tutorials and answers for your other questions.
Bonus: Consulting
Consulting can happen at any point in your publishing process, whether that’s just once at the end to triple check everything is in order, interspersed questions throughout, or walking you through the whole process. It’s truly a new indie author’s best friend! A trustworthy consultant is friendly, knowledgeable, keeps you in charge, and is clear about pricing. It’s a great option anytime you feel like you need a little more guidance.
You did it! Whether by hiring editors, asking friends, or braving it alone, you’ve now bettered your manuscript and feel confident about the content. Well done! Editing is a difficult process, but it’s all about making sure you share something you’re proud of. It’s time to take a breather, because there’s more work ahead.
In the coming articles, we’ll be addressing more of the most frequently asked editing questions from new (overwhelmed) independent authors.
- What is an advance reader copy?
- Can I format my own book?
- How do I developmentally edit my own book?
- How do I line edit my own book?
~Allison of Sigmon Editorial
From idea to ISBN, Sigmon Editorial’s got your back.








